Should I Get a Shower or Bathtub? Which One Increases Value More?

Thinking about upgrading your bathroom? A shower or a bathtub—seems like a simple choice, right? But once you start considering your daily routine, bathroom space, and even home value, the decision can feel a bit more complicated. If you plan to sell in the future, you might also be wondering—which one adds more value 

The answer depends on your lifestyle, available space, and what future buyers might prefer. Let’s break down the key factors to help you decide. 

Shower vs. Bathtub: What’s the Real Difference? 

Showers are quick and efficient—get in, clean up, and move on with your day. Bathtubs, on the other hand, are designed for relaxation and unwinding. 

The right choice depends on how you use your bathroom. If you never take baths, installing a tub just for aesthetics won’t benefit you. But if you love soaking after a long day, skipping the bathtub might be a mistake. 

But aside from personal taste, there's one more huge question—how does each choice impact your home's value? Let's analyze. 

When a Shower is the Better Choice 

• If You Value Convenience 

  
  

Showers are quick. If you're always running in the morning, a bathtub will likely just collect dust. A shower is the most convenient choice for everyday life. You get in, clean up in five minutes, and you're out the door. 

• If Your Bathroom is Small 

  
  

Bathtubs take up a lot of space. In a small bathroom, squeezing in a tub can make the whole room feel cramped. A sleek walk-in shower can make a small space feel bigger and more open. 

• If You’re Thinking About Accessibility 

  
  

Showers, particularly walk-in showers, are simpler to use for seniors and individuals with mobility impairments. No climbing over tall tub walls, no slipping hazard getting in and out. If you're going to be living in your home for the long haul, a shower could be the more intelligent option. 

• If You Want to Save Water 

  
  

On average, showering for five minutes takes less water than tub filling. To save on the water bill, a shower would be a more sensible option. (That is, unless you take long steamy showers where you'll potentially use as much water as the bath.)  

• If You Want a Modern Look 

  
  

An efficient walk-in shower will immediately turn a bathroom more chic and current. Glass surrounds, rain showerheads, and smooth tile designs all contribute an upscale ambiance to an area. If you simply want to refresh and modernize your bathroom, a shower would be the preferred choice. 

When a Bathtub is the Right Investment 

• If You Love to Unwind 

  
  

If soaking in a warm bath is your idea of self-care, don’t skip the tub. A shower can’t replace that level of relaxation. 

• If You Have (or Plan to Have) Kids 

  
  

Bathing little children in a shower isn't necessarily convenient. If you have little children—or will, anyway—having a bathtub will be a whole lot easier. Families with little children tend to find a bathtub an essential item. 

• If You Want a Touch of Luxury 

  
  

Bathtubs, especially freestanding or soaking tubs, add a sense of luxury to a bathroom. If you’re going for a spa-like feel, a bathtub can instantly elevate the space. A well-placed soaking tub can make a bathroom look high-end, even if the rest of the home is simple. 

• If You’re Thinking About Resale Value 

  
  

Lack of a bathtub may be a turnoff for some buyers—particularly families. In larger homes with multiple bathrooms, at least one should have a bathtub to appeal to more buyers. Although a walk-in shower may be the "in" thing, a house without a bathtub may discourage some buyers. 

• If You Plan to Stay in Your Home for a Long Time 

  
  

Even if resale value isn't an issue at the moment, consider how your needs may shift in the future. You may not be concerned about bathing today, but you might be later on. A strategically placed bathtub can make your home feel more whole in the future. 

Which One Adds More Value? 

Now, the million-dollar question—does a shower or bathtub add more value to your home? 

Real estate experts recommend that every home should have at least one bathtub. If your home has only one bathroom, removing the tub for a shower could hurt resale value—especially for buyers with children. But if you already have a tub in another bathroom, upgrading to a modern walk-in shower could make your home more appealing. 

But if you already have a tub in a different bathroom, swapping one out for a modern, walk-in shower can really make your home more desirable. In smaller homes, a roomy, fashion-forward shower can attract buyers seeking something sleek and modern. 

In luxury homes, a soaking tub can be a major selling point. But in smaller homes, buyers may prefer a spacious shower over a cramped bathtub. 

 The key is balance. If your home has multiple bathrooms, having at least one with a tub and one with a shower is ideal. If you’re in a one-bathroom home, removing the only bathtub might not be the best move. 

The Best of Both Worlds 

If you don't want to decide, you don't have to. A shower-tub combination provides both options. It's convenient, space-saving, and makes future buyers smile. It may not have the sleek look of a walk-in shower or the complete luxury of a freestanding tub, but it's the most versatile option. 

If you are renovating and have room, another excellent choice is a tub and shower separately. This arrangement provides the ultimate in both convenience and luxury—hasty showers when you must have them and relaxing baths when you need to relax. 

So, What Should You Choose? 

If you are a speed and convenience person, a shower is the way to go. If you enjoy soaking in the bathtub or have children, a tub may be a better option. And if you are considering resale value, your home should at least have one tub before replacing any. 

Final Thoughts:

Choose what fits your lifestyle first. Your bathroom should meet your needs today, but it’s always smart to consider future buyers if you plan to sell.